When to Hire a Bookkeeper for Your Startup?

Luke Frye, CPA
Category: Puzzle Guides

For early-stage startups, every resource counts and every decision can pivot your trajectory. With recent breakthroughs in AI and tech, founders find themselves at a fascinating crossroads — when to embrace technology and when to invest in human expertise?

The Role of Accounting Software for Startups

Your accounting software is your financial Swiss Army knife. For founders, the value lies in turning their focus from mundane repetitive tasks to mission-critical ones. 

Software that automates bank reconciliations, transaction categorizations, invoices, payroll and payment matching acts like a high-performing backend team member—diligent, error-proof, and relentlessly efficient.

Think of bank reconciliations as a puzzle: missing a single piece can skew the entire picture. Frustrating in puzzles, disastrous in finance. With the right accounting software and bookkeeping, you'll have every single puzzle piece accounted for and a part of a complete and accurate financial picture of your company.

When to Hire a Professional?

Regardless of how powerful your accounting software is, you will eventually need help with navigating the nuanced terrain of startup finance. The human element— professionals like CPAs and bookkeepers—brings a layer of strategic depth, problem-solving, and foresight that is harder for algorithms to replicate.

Engaging a bookkeeper or accountant becomes crucial when the complexity of financial decisions transcends the binary logic of software. Whether it's navigating tax strategies, financial planning, or solving unique challenges, the expertise of a seasoned professional is irreplaceable.

When to Hire In-House for This Role?

It's all about making the smart moves at the right time, balancing agility with the right level of expertise. Hiring an in-house bookkeeper or accountant depends on the size of your business, the complexity of your finances, and your growth trajectory.

When financial management becomes a bottleneck to growth or strategic decision-making, it's time to consider bringing that expertise in-house.

There's a point where scales begin to tip towards hiring in-house:

  1. Complexity Creeps In: When you need more and more specific, day-to-day oversight, it's time to think about having someone on your team to handle it.
  2. Strategic Depth Required: There comes a stage where financial strategy intertwines with every decision you make as a founder. Having an in-house finance expert who's as invested in your vision as you are can help.

  3. Economies of Scale: Crunch the numbers. If the outsourcing costs start to outpace the investment in an in-house bookkeeper, it's a clear signal that it's time to bring someone onboard.

  4. Navigating Compliance and Regulations: As you scale, compliance and regulation become more complex. You’ll struggle to automate this. 

Can I Outsource These Tasks?

Before diving headfirst into hiring an in-house finance team, outsourcing financial tasks can be a good interim solution.

Traditionally, engaging with professional accounting services was time-consuming and complicated. At Puzzle, we've taken this concept and simplified it to a few clicks, understanding that startups don't just need the tools, but access to human expertise. We have a network of certified finance professionals—bookkeepers, CPAs, and more that you can connect with whenever you need. 

Why outsourcing first makes sense:

  1. Cost-Efficiency: Conserving cash while getting high-quality advice is the ideal scenario.

  2. Flexibility: Startups are all about evolution, and your financial needs today might be different tomorrow. When outsourcing, you can scale your finance support up or down easily.

  3. Diverse Expertise: When you have a network of finance experts, you can find someone specific to your industry and stage.

  4. Focus: While you're out there changing the world, finance tasks can be a distraction. Outsourcing keeps you laser-focused on your mission.

Our platform isn't just about filling gaps; it's about giving you the strategic advantage with access to a network of finance professionals tailored to your startup's unique journey.

How Professionals and Software Can Work Together

The transition to hiring an in-house bookkeeper or accountant doesn't mean abandoning software; you’re simply shifting to a more integrated financial management approach. 

The relationship between accounting software and professionals is not adversarial but complementary.

Software can handle the day-to-day bookkeeping tasks, while professionals can focus on more complex and strategic financial decisions for your business. Leverage the best of both worlds—efficiency and expertise.

Automating the Mundane with Software

The heart of accounting efficiency lies in automation - specifically, manual and error-prone tasks like bank reconciliations, payment and expense matching, invoicing, financial statements and transaction categorizations. 

By automating the mundane yet critical task of recording financial transactions, you're making sure all receipts and transactions are accurately categorized and recorded. This makes the end-of-year rush to update financial records and prepare your business for tax season much less stressful.

Tax preparation and auditing are often overlooked in the early stages, but they are crucial for ensuring compliance, validating financial integrity, and building trust with investors and stakeholders.

When your tax preparer asks for your financial records, you can simply give them the access to your dashboard. Puzzle's platform acts as a single source of truth for your financial data, eliminating the need to compile and send multiple documents.

This direct approach eliminates the need for the endless back-and-forth.

Bookkeeping and Real-Time Financial Oversight

At its core, bookkeeping isn’t just about keeping records; it’s about helping founders make informed decisions for their business. By accurately tracking sales, expenses, and daily financial transactions, startups gain a clear picture of their cash flow, burn rate and runway. 

The ultimate goal of any business is to be profitable. This requires managing current finances and strategically planning for future growth. Real-time insight into startup metrics helps founders understand their profit margins and identify opportunities for optimization—whether through cost reduction, pricing strategies, or revenue diversification.

Financial management is not just a function, but a strategic asset driving your business forward. It's about recognizing that in the fast-paced world of startups, the right mix of technology and talent isn't just beneficial—it's essential.

Share this post
Luke Frye, CPA
Recovering CPA a.k.a Head of Customer Success

Related posts